The same fight always starts as something small. A text sent to remind your partner of the plans you carefully curated, only to feel slighted when they show up ten minutes late. A hand you place on theirs at a party to signal you’re ready to leave, only to feel them pull their hand away, lost in the conversation they’re already having. The subtle pang of loneliness you feel even on the couch next to your partner, as both of your eyes land on your phones instead of each other.
You might be the partner always reaching: feeling both scared to let go of the cognitive load you carry to make sure you two have quality time together, and resentful of carrying it alone. You might be the partner who constantly retreats: the one who feels caught between abandoning your own needs for your partners, or massively triggering your partner when you tend to your own. Either way, each of you is locked into a dance that neither of you signed up for, feeling resentful, lonely, and confused about what to do.
The good news: none of this signals that either partner has something wrong with them, or that the relationship is doomed to fail. The excellent news: both of you have the capacity to understand the layers of the conflict choreography, discerning which steps are yours and which are your partner’s. And once you two can see the steps clearly, you two have power: the power to fight effectively, to mutually craft a more satisfying, connected, and individuated dance—with enough space for each of you to move and feel, and enough closeness to respond to and celebrate the magic you two create when dancing together.
Why Couples Keep Having the Same Fight
On the surface, the fight probably feels like it’s about the different perceptions of the situation: one partner whose text landed as naggy and overbearing, and the other partner’s delayed response as cold, inconsiderate, and distant. It might also feel like it’s about who’s “allowed” to say what they want and who has to suffer in silence.
But when we look under the hood, we see that this pattern has much more to do with each partner fighting for disparate needs at the same time, needs that likely went unmet in their family of origin. Esther Perel’s perennial wisdom poses this reframe: instead of asking, “what are we fighting about,” move to asking “what is each of us fighting for?”
Perel asserts that most couples fight to meet these three core needs: power and control, care and closeness, and respect and recognition (Perel & Miller, 2021). When a partner is fighting for power and control, they are fighting for agency, decision-making power, and to sense that their own preferences matter. When a partner fights for care and closeness, they’re wanting to know that their partner can offer the care they need, care they can depend on, as in, “Will you be there for me when I need you? Or when I’m not at my best?” When a partner fights for respect and recognition, they are fighting for their values to matter to the other, for their efforts (either for their partner or for their relationship) to be recognized, affirmed, and appreciated.
Each Partner Has a Role: Untangling a Web into Two Distinct Strands
In this dance, each partner usually takes one of two roles: the pursuer, who reaches harder when they sense distance, and the distancer, who pulls back when the intensity rises. Neither role is a flaw. Each is a set of steps learned early, for good reason. You’ll meet the pursuer and the distancer in the next two posts of this series, coming over the next two weeks.
Why This Dance Is No One’s Fault
Maybe you were envisioning the couple as a woman pursuer and a man distancer—but research has shown that these dynamics occur just as much in same-sex couples as in heterosexual ones, and that who is in which role has much more to do with socialized power dynamics, as opposed to physiological differences between sexes. In a study of 63 heterosexual, gay, and lesbian couples, researchers found the pattern in every type of couple and concluded that “a variable indicative of power differences, rather than essential differences between the men and women, better accounts for differences in demand-withdraw behavior” (Holley et al., 2010).
Often what draws us to each other in relationship can be the very same thing that presents an issue down the road. The distancer, who has a harder time accessing their feelings, gets to experience the richness and vitality of a partner who expresses openly and honestly. The pursuer, whose emotions can feel unmooring, gets to experience a grounding and a calming perspective with a partner who isn’t as easily rattled.
The very same survival strategy that felt attractive, new, and vitalizing can be the very same one evoking the same fight over and over. In most scenarios, no one partner is fully at fault—all dynamics, even ones with power differentials, are co-created, meaning each of you participates in shaping what happens in the space between the two of you. Put simply, as relationship expert Dr. Alexandra Solomon explains in her couples therapy course I recently completed: “my stuff + your stuff = our stuff.”
Try This the Next Time You’re Caught in the Same Conflict Dance
Here are three concrete steps to start re-choreographing the duet you never wanted to star in.
The second you notice a familiar behavior pop up (that passive-aggressive comment, the silent return to your phone), PAUSE. Then take note of all of the emotions you’re feeling and how they show up in your body. For example, “I’m feeling anxious, bummed, and lonely. The anxiety feels like a pulsing in my head, the bummed a pit in my stomach, and the lonely like a hollow, empty feeling in my chest.”
Breathe—deeply in and out, through the nose! (And yes, I know we therapists love reminding people to breathe, but for good reason!) Breath will encourage your nervous system to move from high-alert threat detection to a collaborative, curious, and compassionate state. It will also literally lengthen the time between impulse and action, offering more time to consider what response will actually be effective.
Make the implicit, explicit. The old habit, like the passive-aggressive comment, communicates the need, but not in a direct way. The new habit puts your need or desire underneath the criticism front and center. Say to your partner, “I’m noticing that habit of mine popped up again. Let me try again. I’m actually feeling _____ (sad, lonely). I think my emotions might be saying I could use some closeness right now.”
Bonus tip: Bio-hack your fight. Try to discuss the conflict in physical positions that cue your body to calm down, like lying down on the floor, facing the ceiling, or walking in the park side by side. These postures tell the nervous system, “ok, seems like we might be in rest-and-digest time,” and facing the same way, rather than each other, can help you feel less adversarial, and less triggered by your partner’s response.
Curious what’s happening in both of your bodies in the middle of the fight? That’s coming in the final post of this series.
Feeling like your relationship needs support in rewriting your specific conflict choreography? Book a consult today.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it normal to have the same fight over and over?
Absolutely. According to relationship experts the Gottmans, “most conflict (69%) in relationships is perpetual” (Gottman Institute Couples Retreats, n.d.), meaning about 7/10 of the arguments you have with your partner keep coming back, like a song stuck on repeat. The goal is NOT to avoid conflict, as conflict is an important and inevitable part of being in relationship, romantic or otherwise. The goal is to understand how to fight effectively, so that conflict becomes a way to both understand yourself and your partner better, as well as bring you two closer together in repair.
How do you stop having the same fight?
Instead of focusing on the context, what each of you is fighting about, focus on what need each of you is trying to meet: what you’re each fighting for. Suddenly, each of you moves from a defensive to a curious stance. Then, notice what’s happening in your body, what emotions are present. Then breathe. Although a therapist recommending breathing is one of the most trite suggestions you’ve probably ever seen, it helps for two reasons. It helps shift your nervous system from fight/flight into rest/digest, and it actually lengthens the time between trigger (that critical comment, for example) and response, which is where the opportunity for change lies.
Can couples therapy help if we keep having the same argument?
Again, absolutely. A recurring pattern of conflict is one of the most common reasons couples (of all genders, sexual orientations, and relationship frameworks) come to see me. In somatic couples therapy, we’ll slow the pattern down so that each of you can see your steps and your partner’s steps much more clearly. Then we can investigate and hold space for what stories your body holds underneath those steps, and choreograph a new dance: one that may still feel intense, but ends with each of you feeling closer, rather than even further apart. If you’re curious, schedule a free consult call to learn more.
Sources
Gottman Institute Couples Retreats. (n.d.). Research findings.
Holley, S. R., Sturm, V. E., & Levenson, R. W. (2010). Exploring the basis for gender differences in the demand-withdraw pattern. Journal of Homosexuality, 57, 666–684.
Perel, E., & Miller, M. A. (2021, June 29). The 3 types of relationship fights you keep having—and what to do about them.
Solomon, A. H. (2024). Dr. Alexandra Solomon's Couple Therapy Certification: Start-to-Finish Intensive Training Program [Online course]. PESI.